The shortlist Tips What we check Method FAQ Compare

Prop Challenge Attempt and Payout Journal

Track attempts, fees, breaches and payouts without inventing a success rate from selected screenshots.

Rulebook desk research checked 8 October 2026. No evaluation purchase, enforcement test or payout verification is represented.

Define an Attempt Before Counting

Specify when an attempt starts, what ends it and how a reset is recorded. Keep a purchase identifier, programme version and phase. A free practice account, a paid evaluation and a later account are different observations. Combining them creates a denominator that cannot support a meaningful result.

For personal recordkeeping, include every attempt in the selected period. A failed attempt that was replaced by a reset still incurred time and possibly money. Do not erase it from the history when a later attempt succeeds. If a record is unavailable, mark it missing rather than assuming it passed or failed.

Separate the Milestones

Record purchase, first trading date, evaluation completion, later account activation, payout eligibility, payout request and actual receipt as separate events where applicable. A screenshot announcing a pass does not demonstrate a received payout. A requested withdrawal does not demonstrate that funds arrived.

Keep the account's stated simulated or live status explicit for each phase. Do not describe a marketing account-size label as personally withdrawable capital. The contractual route determines what the participant can receive and under which conditions.

Reconcile Cash Costs

Use actual receipts for purchase, resets, subscriptions, platform and data charges. Record currency conversion and tax separately when relevant. A refund or credit should retain its original transaction link. Do not subtract an unreceived promotional reward from the cost ledger.

A personal ledger can show your own net cash experience over a defined period. It cannot estimate the firm's population pass rate. A representative study needs a complete candidate cohort, outcome definitions, observation time and missing-data treatment. This publication has none of that private population data.

Preserve Breach Evidence

If a boundary is breached, record the applicable rule, metric, time and account statement. A final balance above a limit may not describe the earlier intraday equity path. Conversely, an unexplained dashboard state should not be treated as proven rule enforcement without the supporting record.

Keep support correspondence and distinguish a confirmed violation from a dispute. Redact account identifiers before sharing a consumer review. Describe the specific evidence and unresolved question without asserting malicious intent or generalising one account to every customer.

Use the Journal to Set Boundaries

Compare the attempt's total cost and time with your predeclared budget. A previous fee is already spent; it does not make another attempt more likely to succeed. Decide when to pause or stop from the plan, not from a desire to recover sunk costs immediately.

This site offers a record structure, not a recommendation to buy repeated evaluations. We have not purchased a challenge or verified a payout. No named firm's success percentage or individual trader's passing probability is manufactured for the directory.

Primary Sources

Prop Account Headroom Worksheet

Related research

Add payment state to the attempt journal

The new cash packet complements the retained attempt discussion by separating posted, pending and void rows. It groups entered amounts by category and opaque attempt identity. A payout request is not a settled payment, and a possible refund is not current cash. The fictional base journal has two attempts and eight events; it is not a study of repeated evaluations. Its totals do not establish typical costs, a pass rate or expected return. Preserve the actual source for any real payment status. If an earlier attempt is missing, the tool cannot discover it, so a complete population list remains a separate evidence requirement.

Keep the original source relationship

Attach the cited source to the precise field it supports. A rule URL supports its observed wording; an account record supports an observed event; a cash record supports its supplied payment status. None of those records establishes the others automatically. The publication's practice packet is deliberately authored, with no participant population. Use it to inspect the relationship between input and output rather than as evidence that a programme, provider or trading method achieved the displayed result. Missing fields remain unresolved, and the responsible account process owns any real eligibility decision.

A worked contrast to investigate

In the invented packet a close at an entered window endpoint changes classification when the endpoint operator changes. In the separate cash journal a pending refund changes the balance only after the status is changed to posted. These controlled contrasts do not prove a named firm's policy. They show why the record needs an explicit operator or status. Export the supplied inputs with the result, retain the applicable product card separately and preserve uncertainty about missing events. A precise calculation is useful when its scope remains visible; it is misleading when presented as an account approval or a measured participant outcome.

Preparation records